LifeStyle & Health

22 Bestselling Toppers That Make Mattresses Feel Brand-Spanking New

We get it: buying a new bestselling mattress is an ordeal that’s a huge investment for both our finances and general wellbeing. But today, instead of pushing ourselves and our budgets to pull the purchase trigger on one, we’re here to talk toppers — aka the affordable solution to upgrading that tired old box spring.

We hunted down the best mattress toppers with the highest reviews from top bedding brands across the web, sharpening them down into the hit list ahead. There’s a premium pad for every type of sleeper, from memory foam to hypoallergenic and eco-friendly styles. A lighter (but still supportive) investment in your snooze space is just an add-to-cart click away.

Welcome to Hype Machine, our hit-list of the top reviewed products across the web — according to a crowd of die-hard shoppers. Call this your 4-star & up only club, with entry granted by our devoted-to-the-goods shop editors.

At Refinery29, we’re here to help you navigate this overwhelming world of stuff. All of our market picks are independently selected and curated by the editorial team. If you buy something we link to on our site, Refinery29 may earn commission.

Brooklinen Down Alternative Mattress Topper

Best For: A Heavenly Breathable Sleep
This down alternative mattress topper is made from soft microgel material with a 100% organic cotton cover and tufted top.

The Hype: 4.7 out of 5 stars

Sleepers Say: “Heaven! We bought a new mattress, and my hubby said he wanted more smooosh on top. I didn’t want to be hotter. The down alternative mattress topper makes us both SO happy! Aaaahhhhh…..” – Harriet M., Brooklinen Reviewer

Shop Brooklinen

Brooklinen Down Alternative Mattress Topper, $, available at Brooklinen

Therapedic Tru-Cool 3-Inch Serene Foam Performance Mattress Topper

Best For: A Cloud-Like Refreshing Sleep
Therapedic’s Tru-Cool mattress is made extra supportive through billions of microscopic air capsules that ease pressure on the body.

The Hype: 4 out of 5 stars

Sleepers Say: “This is a bouncier, soft foam. For me personally, it is a match made in mattress topper heaven. I get excited to go to bed now. I am someone who does not like dense, slow moving foams. I do not like a firm bed. I have a firm mattress and purchased this to get the feel of sleeping on a soft comfy cloud and that’s what I received. If you are someone who prefers soft and bouncy toppers then you will love it. If you are someone who likes a firm dense foam then I don’t think it’s for you. I recommend going into the store and feeling the sample they have. My quality of sleep has sky rocketed. Also, it is made in the USA and that’s a big deal to me.” – Ginger, Bed Bath & Beyond Reviewer

Shop Therapedic

Saatva Saatva Mattress Toppers, $, available at Saatva

Saatva Mattress Topper

Best For: Customizable Sleep
Saatva’s premium, three-inch toppers are available in three material options for different sleep styles: graphite for hot sleepers who want to temperature regulation; latex for sleepers looking for sustainably made body support; or performance foam for sleepers in need of contoured pressure relief.

The Hype: 5 out of 5 stars

Sleepers Say: “Best in the market — totally worth paying the extra for this mattress pad. It’s comfortable, doesn’t need shaking, and is perfect for a hard mattress.” – Sally, Saatva Reviewer

Shop Saatva

Saatva Saatva Mattress Toppers, $, available at Saatva

Tempur-Pedic Temper-Topper Supreme

Best For: Personalized Supportive Sleep
This mattress topper is made from 3 inches of you guessed it, the same stand-out TEMPUR® material that’s found in all of Tempur-Pedics legendary body forming mattresses. The topper adjusts to individual body weight, shape, and temperature for an unmatched personalized sleep experience. Added bonus, a removable and washable cover is included, which is resistant to mold and allergens.

The Hype: 4.6 out of 5 stars

Sleepers Say: “I absolutely love the 3 inch topper. Every night, I sink in feeling supported all around. I am definitely sleeping better – waking up less each night.” – Anonymous, Tempur-Pedic Reviewer

Shop Tempur-Pedic

Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Topper Supreme, $, available at Tempur-Pedic

Parachute Down Mattress Topper

Best For: Five-Star Hotel Sleep
For a more classic style topper, Parachute’s featherbed style filled with premium European white down has your mattress covered. With a 100% sateen-cotton shell and a stay-in-place baffle-box construction, it provides three inches of plush “five-star hotel feel.”

The Hype: 4.4 out of 5 stars

Sleepers Say: “Obsessed!! The down feather bed is a game-changer. The only negative is that it makes getting out of bed nearly impossible. I have both the down and the down alternative feather beds and like them both but if I had to pick one, I would choose the down version. These feather beds are luxurious and comfortable and have eliminated any shoulder and knee pains I used to experience while sleeping. I have bought other mattress toppers from Amazon that were less expensive, but they aren’t comparable. Spend the extra money; you’ll be happy you did.” – Birgit, Parachute Reviewer

Shop Parachute

Parachute Down Mattress Topper, $, available at Parachute

Tuft & Needle Mattress Topper

Best For: An Ache Free Slumber
Tuft & Needle’s mattress topper is the solution for anyone trying to make their firm mattress a little easier on the joints. It’s made of responsive foam to relieve pressure points on hips and shoulders and keeps you cool all night.

The Hype: 4.4 out of 5 stars

Sleepers Say: “Finally getting some good rest. Our mattress “caused” aches in my shoulders and hips. I frequently had to turn over in bed, like a rotisserie chicken, trying to relieve pressure points. With this mattress topper, I don’t have to do that!” – Anonymous, Tuft & Needle Reviewer

Shop Tuft & Needle

Tuft & Needle Mattress Topper, $, available at Tuft & Needle

Boll & Branch Mattress Topper

Best For: A Softer Feel
Made with 2 inches of organic cotton, wool, and poly, this topper adds an extra layer of pillow-soft comfort for any sleeper wanting a bit more cushion.

The Hype: 5 out of 5 stars

Sleepers Say: “I purchased the mattress topper for my very firm, 12 year old mattress to accommodate my boyfriend’s clear preference for a softer bed. He is sleeping much better now and I found myself surprised to discover I love the luxurious feel myself. Definitely recommend.” – Amy R., Boll & Branch Reviewer

Shop Boll & Branch

Boll & Branch The Mattress Topper, $, available at Boll & Branch

Layla Memory Foam Topper

Best For: Soft But Supportive Sleep
If you’re in the market for a sleep experience described as “like adding an extra layer of clouds to a bed already made of cotton candy,” then Laya’s topper crafted from cooling, copper-gel-infused memory foam has your number.

The Hype: 4.5 out of 5 stars

Sleepers Say: “We’ve had it a couple of months now and this thing seriously transformed our Costco mattress (the wife and I were a little let down by the firmness of it). Adding this gave it that plush feel we were looking for. It helped a ton with side sleeping and laying on my back is more comfortable as well.” – Charles J, Layla Reviewer

Shop Layla

Layla Sleep Memory Foam Topper, $, available at Layla Sleep

Coop Home Goods Flip Mattress Topper

Best For: Firm OR Soft Sleep
This 4-inch memory foam topper packs reversible powers that offer the option of both soft and firm support — plus, it also comes bundled with a 100% waterproof mattress protector, 100-night sleep trial, and five-year limited warranty.

The Hype: 5 out of 5 stars

Sleepers Say: “We recently decided that our mattress was too soft and had been mattress shopping. After getting a price quote way out of our budget, we decided to go back to the drawing board to find something more affordable for the time being. I loved the fact that you can flip this topper to be softer or firmer. So far, we have only used the firm side, but it made our bed exact support that we have been looking for without feeling like we were sleeping on the concrete floor! We really liked the cover that lets you strap the topper to your bed, it really keeps it in place instead of having it slide all over the place while you’re sleeping. It did add some height to my mattress, which I personally love, and BONUS my Solstice sheets still fit great even with the added height. The packaging was awesome, it came vacuum sealed and I would definitely recommend this to anyone that’s looking for more support with their mattress or, to make their mattress a little softer.” – Audrey, Coop Home Goods Reviewer

Shop Coop Home Goods

Coop Home Goods Flip Mattress Topper, $, available at Coop Home Goods

Avocado Green Organic Latex Mattress Topper

Best For: Sustainable Sleep
Pricey for a cause: this eco-friendly topper is handmade from sustainable GOLS-certified organic cotton, wool, and latex materials that pass a rigorous screening test for third-party emissions standards (and rigorous customer approval for premium-levels of sleep support).

The Hype: 4.6 out of 5 stars

Sleepers Say: “Best Purchase! We recently purchased a bed/mattress combo and found it was not comfortable at all. We couldn’t return just the mattress because we bought it together. We decided to give the Avocado Green Natural Latex Mattress Topper a try to see if it could save us from the hassle of having to return our entire bed/mattress purchase. It sure did! We are extremely satisfied with our purchase. Had we known about Avocado before, we would have bought their mattress instead. This is an excellent product that I highly recommend for anyone struggling with needing a good night’s rest. Who doesn’t need a good night’s rest? We’re completely satisfied.” – Mary, Avocado Reviewer

Shop Avocado

Avocado Green Mattress Topper, $, available at Avocado

Dream Science By Martha Stewart Quilted Mattress Pad

Best For: Classic Comfort
The price is definitely right on this super-soft classic quilted mattress topper from the OG herself, Martha.

The Hype: 4.4 out of 5 stars

Sleepers Say: “To me, this is a perfect mattress pad; it is soft and has a nice thickness to it. It fits my full mattress perfectly. I highly recommend.” – Arlene, Macy’s Reviewer

Shop Dream Science By Martha Stewart

Dream Science by Martha Stewart Collection Quilted Mattress Pad, $, available at Macy’s

Lucid Lavender Infused Memory Foam Mattress Topper

Best For: Serene Sleep
What sets this three-inch memory foam topper apart from the rest? A subtle lavender-scent infusion that promotes an even calmer, cozier, and supportive sleep space.

The Hype: 4.5 out of 5 stars

Sleepers Say: “100% worth it! I have degenerative disc disease and arthritis in my neck that causes back and shoulder pain. I needed to buy a new mattress which couldn’t have been worse timing that I was also strapped for cash and I ‘splurged’ on a not so comfy spring mattress for a whopping $200… enter sarcasm here. I just didn’t have the funds for a nice one and the springs were killing my back and also leaving sore spots on my hips and shoulders to the point where it felt like I should be covered in bruises. I bought one of these toppers and I haven’t slept this well in months. No more pain and the lavender scent is just enough but not overpowering.” – Learn, Amazon Reviewer

Shop Lucid

Lucid 3″ Lavender Infused Memory Foam Mattress Topper (Queen), $, available at Amazon

MOLECULE Airtec Mattress Topper

Best For: Pain-Free Sleep
This topper is Air-Engineered™ for a recovery-focused comfortable and cooling sleep. It’s three unique layers are designed to conform to your body to deliver enhanced pressure relief and support and provides maximum airflow.

The Hype: 4.5 out of 5 stars

Sleepers Say: “Its hard to believe and even harder to say out loud, but the first morning after sleeping on the MOLECULE Airtec mattress topper was the day everything changed! I woke up pain-free and I’m not kidding nor lying! I drive for a living and I’m in a constant back and hip pain. When I first stood up from bed ‘I didn’t recognize the feeling…The feeling of nothing”! For the first time in 20+ years I didn’t hurt.” – Cathy, MOLECULE Reviewer

Shop Molecule

Molecule AirTEC Mattress Topper, $, available at Molecule

Wayfair Sleep Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper

Best For: Sweat-Free Sleep
Say hello to two-and-a-half inches of cooling mattress rejuvenation for under $100 — this topper is made from CertiPUR-US-certified gel memory foam that’s water-resistant, hypoallergenic, and backed by a three-year warranty.

The Hype: 4.7 out of 5 stars

Sleepers Say: “It’s like a giant cloud hugging you to sleep. I sleep so well with this top. If you don’t want to spend the money on a new mattress just yet, add this and it’ll feel brand new!” – Ashley, Wayfair Reviewer

Shop Wayfair Sleep

Wayfair Sleep 2.5″ Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper, $, available at Wayfair

Zinus Spa Sensations AirFlow Visco Elastic Foam Topper

Best For: Breathable Sleep
Two inches of Visco Elastic air foam combine with one inch of an infusion of green tea and charcoal memory foam — aka three whole inches of breathable and odor-neutralizing sleep support.

The Hype: 4.4 out of 5 stars

Sleepers Say: “My mattress is only 2 1/2 years old and I started having lower back problems and I didn’t want to purchase a new one. So I searched for a mattress topper for almost a week. The Spa sensation 3 airflow had the best reviews. I’ve been sleeping on the mattress for over a week now and my back feels so much better! I love this mattress, I sleep so much better and I am getting a solid nights sleep again!” – Gotagoodsleep, Walmart Reviewer

Shop Zinus

Zinus Spa Sensations AirFlow Visco Elastic Foam Topper, $, available at Walmart

Amerisleep Lift Mattress Topper

Best For: High-Tech Sleep
Designed with Bio-Pur and Affinity materials that provide a cooling sleep-feel, HIVE technology that promotes total-body pressure relief, and a Micro-Grip base layer that prevents slippage, this total-package topper has more than earned its tip-top reviewer rating.

The Hype: 4.7 out of 5 stars

Sleepers Say: “I am happy with my mattress topper and my entire experience with Amerisleep. Sounds kind of weird but when I woke up from sleeping on my topper the first night, my husband asked how I felt. I said like butter melting on a pile of warm mashed potatoes. I just melted right in and slept all night long. Prompt delivery. Very well protected merchandise. Amerisleep did what they said and said what they did. I cannot recall ever working with such a considerate team of people. Professional, accurate, friendly, and outstanding products.” – Kimi, Amerisleep Reviewer

Shop Amerisleep

Amerisleep Lift by Amerisleep™ Mattress Topper, $, available at Amerisleep

Nest Bedding Alexander Signature Cooling Topper

Best For: Restful Sleep
This two-inch foam topper is crafted from the same luxurious cooling fabric found on the brand’s premium mattresses. And, in addition to increased sleep support and breathability, it also comes with four built-in corner straps for optimal stay-in-place security.

The Hype: 4.7 out of 5 stars

Sleepers Say: “Made our mattress 1000 times more comfortable. We had purchased a mattress from another company before learning of Nest. That mattress was way too firm for us, so we purchased this cooling topper from Nest (after feeling and loving it on a friend’s bed). It was the best decision! What a huge difference! I wake up every morning so rested! I just never want to get out of bed!!!” – Erika, Nest Bedding Reviewer

Shop Nest Bedding

Nest Bedding Alexander Signature Cooling Topper (Full), $, available at Nest Bedding

The Company Store Down Alternative Baffled Featherbed

Best For: Featherbed-Alternative Sleep
If you love the soft-feathered feel that a down topper provides but can’t handle the allergens that come with it, this still-as-soft style is a perfect alternative. The TCS Down-free fill is stuffed inside 4-inch deep and 15-inch wide baffled-quilted squares that make for a fully lofted “sink-right-in” sleep situation.

The Hype: 4.5 out of 5 stars

Sleepers Say: “I got this product to soften the mattress of my as-yet-to-be-delivered camper van. I was going to get foam, but foam can be very heavy and awkward, so I thought of featherbeds (which can be rolled up or stuffed into corners). I didn’t want to bother with actual feathers or down, too much trouble on the road. Hence, this down-free version. I tried it on my own bed and enjoyed the way I sort-of sank into it. Very cozy, very cushy. There was some compression, however. Easily fixed by a brief shakeout. There seems to be some confusion about featherbeds – under the bottom sheet or over? If you want to give yours a shake in the morning, to fluff it up, it has to go over the sheet. Otherwise, you’d have to unmake your whole bed. So I bought two of the 100% cotton featherbed covers and sleep directly on the featherbed. They zip on, zip off, and are washable. Problem solved. You could even use a small duvet cover over it, like a flannel one in Winter. Anyway, this is a fine product and highly recommended.” – Vickety, The Company Store Reviewer

Shop The Company Store

The Company Store Down Alternative Baffled Featherbed, $, available at The Company Store

Linenspa Gel Infused Memory Foam Mattress Topper

Best For: Affordable Sleep
This under-$50 option boasts over 11,000 reviews and Choice status on Amazon. Crafted out of ultra-plush memory foam that’s infused with temperature-regulating gel beads, the two- to three-inch toppers are designed to provide pressure-relief and spine-alignment support.

The Hype: 4.5 out of 5 stars

Sleepers Say: “Instant comfort upgrade. We bought an inexpensive memory foam bed for my daughter’s guest room to sleep on when we visit. It seemed OK in the store, but we found it waaaay too firm once we slept on it a few times. We didn’t want to spend the money on a new mattress we use so infrequently, so we decided to go the mattress topper route instead. This was a great solution. The topper expanded to full size in about 4 hours (they recommend up to 24), and we slept much better than we ever have before on that bed. No aches or pains getting up, and no motion transfer during the night. I didn’t notice any smell, even upon first opening the packaging. This was a very affordable solution to an overly firm mattress problem that I would highly recommend to anyone.” – Cowboy Bob, Amazon Reviewer

Shop Linenspa

Linenspa 2-Inch Gel Infused Memory Foam Mattress Topper, Full, $, available at Amazon

Coyuchi Climate Beneficial Wool Mattress Topper

Best For: Supportive Sleep
This eco-conscious brand’s topper is crafted from naturally non-allergenic wool material that’s dust-mite resistant, moisture-wicking, temperature regulating, and offers firmer support that keeps its shape (unlike alternative memory-foam or feather options).

The Hype: 4.8 out of 5 stars

Sleepers Say: “I bought this mattress topper as an alternative to buying a new mattress. I put it on my 10-year-old mattress and it instantly felt like it was brand new again! I am sleeping better then I have in years and not overheating as I have in the past. Great, great product and a good investment.” – Abby, Coyuchi Reviewer

Shop Coyuchi

Coyuchi Climate Beneficial Wool Mattress Topper, $, available at Coyuchi

Pure Brands Down Alternative Mattress Topper

Best For: Hypoallergenic Sleep
Premium toppers are not memory-foam exclusive — and this Amazon’s Choice plush down-alternative option proves it with its super-plush microfiber material that doubles as a mattress protector.

The Hype: 4.4 out of 5 stars

Sleepers Say: “Soft, cuddly, and comfy!!!! I am SO in love with this product!!! I’d been in between getting a new mattress, topper, or pad — but after I stumbled upon this for the price, IT WAS WELL WORTH IT!!!! Soft, the padding is thick and plushy — it’s like sleeping on a big, fluffy cloud. In fact, it is SO soft, that we didn’t even put sheets on the first night we had it!!!! I am not kidding. It is literally THAT soft. Ever since I received this I can confidently say I’m sleeping well and feel so refreshed. It fits our queen-sized bed PERFECTLY and hides that old, ugly mattress underneath. It’s like having a brand-new bed for less than $40!!!!!” – Teresa, Amazon Reviewer

Shop Pure Brands

Pure Brands Down Alternative Mattress Topper (Full), $, available at Amazon

Casper Mattress Topper

Best For: Reducing Restlessness
This topper is designed to easily fit onto your bed with no slipping and sliding. Crafted with Premium latex foams and a plush top layer, it creates a soft, buoyant feel that keeps you cool, and keeps you still.

The Hype: 4.7 out of 5

Sleepers Say: “I can’t believe I thought I didn’t need a mattress topper before. What a painful life I was living. As a person who tosses and turns all through the night, I found myself sinking into the luscious layers and waking up in the same comfortable spot I fell asleep in the night before. My back feels supported, and my body slowly finds its perfect spot beneath the sheets.” Cortne Bonilla, Lifestyle Writer, Casper Reviewer

Shop Casper

Casper The Layer, $, available at Casper

Like what you see? How about some more R29 goodness, right here?

The Most Breathable Sheets For Super Cool Sleep

The Best Eco-Friendly Bedding Brands

Sex Toy Sales To Shop If You're Stressin'

Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *